IRC log of #maemo for Friday, 2016-06-24

Siceloshe can install those two i suggested00:00
Sicelomaybe they'll give a clue00:00
Juestok00:01
*** xelo has joined #maemo00:06
*** Kilroo has quit IRC00:08
*** sq-one has quit IRC00:11
DocScrutinizer05stock SIP works just fine for me00:13
*** M4rtinK has joined #maemo00:19
JuestWell no idea, using Linphone.org and it doesnt work00:21
Juesti dont receive calls on the pc00:21
* Sicelo has two SIP accounts (free) .. no one to call, haha00:24
JuestAnd apparently i cant call to other networks because it asks authentication :|00:27
JuestSicelo: linphone.org?00:29
Siceloi have that too00:29
JuestWell, it does work but its sort of flacky :(00:30
Sicelowant to call? i've just put it online .. id is the same as my nick00:30
* Juest feels dumb00:30
JuestOkay, with jitsi i'll try00:30
JuestConnecting...00:31
JuestNothing happens :s00:32
Sicelohmm00:32
Sicelosip:<nick>@sip.linphone.org?00:33
JuestYes00:33
Juestand sip: is optional00:34
Juestor maybe not00:34
Siceloon my N900, only ever used sip with my asterisk server (3 years ago)  ... never really used this linphone account00:35
Sicelopm me yours i'll try to call00:35
JuestSicelo: Did a notice... lol00:35
JuestThere it is00:36
Juest(i am using stereo mix for microphone)00:37
Juesti'll try now...00:37
*** eijk has joined #maemo00:37
Sicelolol .. my battery died00:37
DocScrutinizer05(linphone) oh, on PC. well I tested all that was available, like 10 years ago, and finally ended at twinklephone which evolved to become the defacto reference implementation carriers use to test their own services against00:37
JuestApparently i have issues making calls with Jitsi00:37
Juestas well as receiving calls via google talk00:37
Juestlol rip00:38
JuestThank you anyway buddy00:38
Sicelomy battery clearly has too much internal resistance .. had 26%00:39
SiceloJuest: so did you get a call at least?00:39
DocScrutinizer05only downside of twinklephone: it makes thorough use of ALSA unique features which are not available under PukeAudio's crappy ALSA emu00:39
JuestYes, i got a call but i cant call you00:39
JuestAnd my SGS4 GT-I9500 battery sucks00:40
DocScrutinizer05when you can't call out, your registrar server is not working00:40
Sicelohow do you do it? i used the format above ..00:40
Juesti cant use the phone for long periods of time else it drops dead00:40
JuestI am putting just <nick>@sip.linphone.org00:40
Juestwhich is the correct way00:40
SiceloJuest: yes, what DocScrutinizer05 is saying .. linpohone is actually very fussy even on N90000:40
Juestsip: prefix is accepted too00:41
Sicelocheck your configs :)00:41
JuestTried ekiga which was worse00:41
DocScrutinizer05sip.linphone.org, ojmy00:41
JuestJitsi.00:41
JuestOn Windows00:41
Siceloi thought sip: was mandatory .. but then .. /me doesn't use SIP .. wish I would, but no one wants to use it00:41
DocScrutinizer05there were several such crappy "community originated services", I recall ekiga which also never really worked00:41
Juestit is mandatory somewhere else, i am not sure where00:42
Siceloyes, ekiga can't work on N900 due to some setting they need, and N900 can't be set for it00:42
Juestekiga only supports a certain REGISTER approach00:42
DocScrutinizer05I'm talking about the servers00:42
DocScrutinizer05not the client00:43
DocScrutinizer05you know, SIP oughta be SIP00:43
DocScrutinizer05twinklephone can do it all00:43
DocScrutinizer05it has a bazillion config options00:43
SiceloDocScrutinizer05: that's a server? or service? :)00:44
DocScrutinizer05to accomodate the last idiotic server00:44
DocScrutinizer05twinklephone.org00:44
DocScrutinizer05err .com00:44
DocScrutinizer05http://www.twinklephone.com/00:44
Siceloah, client00:45
DocScrutinizer05I'm using it with https://www.sipgate.de/ service00:46
DocScrutinizer05since like 10 years, always works00:46
JuestOh well00:46
JuestSo what SIP free service i should use/be using!?00:47
* Juest hates himself00:47
SiceloJuest: if N900 can do it, then Jitsi should be able .. just recheck your settings. :)00:47
Juestits just stuck on Connecting00:47
JuestAuto DTMF, REGISTER keep-alive, no authorization name, support for encrypted calls enabled (zrtp), SIMPLE presence00:48
JuestThese are the settings00:48
DocScrutinizer05Juest: (which service) that clearly depends on where you're living00:48
JuestThere's barely services....00:49
JuestI am in argentina00:49
JuestOksana's in Australia...00:49
DocScrutinizer05also completely free services are very likely to be shitty, since nobody has something to give away for free00:49
Juestlel00:49
Juestmost of them are european00:50
Sicelotransport - udp, outbound proxy - sip.linphone.org, port 5060, loose routing, REGISTER keep alive,00:50
Juestlinphone uses TLS00:50
DocScrutinizer05I guess there must be international commercial services available now that allow call-out for tiny money, free call-in, and of course free intra-service calls00:50
DocScrutinizer05free world dialup comes to mind, dunno if that still exists00:51
SiceloJuest: can you call others besides Oksana? also, our N900 doesn't do ZRTP. as for TLS .. dunno .. but what i showed above are the 'working' settings that are currently on my n90000:51
JuestNo clue about working ZRTP and sip.linphone.org is the registar00:51
JuestDont have anyone else00:51
DocScrutinizer05hehe, twinkle was the first client to implement ZRTP00:52
JuestWell, i do but different networks doesnt work well00:52
Juestfrom linphone official client it asks me Realm Authentication00:52
DocScrutinizer05get twinkle00:52
JuestYes, theres still dial-up DocScrutinizer05, but most phones dont have such function00:53
DocScrutinizer05huh?00:53
Juesttrue dial-up which is phone call based00:53
DocScrutinizer05you lost me00:53
Juest> free world dialup comes to mind, dunno if that still exists00:53
* Sicelo drifts off to other things ... 00:53
DocScrutinizer05"freworld-dialup" is a company: fwd or somesuch00:54
Sicelolet me know if you/Oksana ever find anything about the skype problem00:54
JuestSure.00:54
Juestlaters sicelo00:54
Juesthave a good night man00:54
Siceloi've ordered two supposedly original batteries .. getting them next week. i hope my N900 will get normal agin00:55
Sicelo*again00:55
DocScrutinizer05http://www.freeworlddialup.com/00:55
DocScrutinizer05http://www.voip-info.org/wiki/view/Free+World+Dialup00:56
DocScrutinizer05http://www.voip-info.org/wiki/view/Sip+Trunking+Providers00:58
*** xelo has joined #maemo01:00
* Juest checks out01:01
DocScrutinizer05and again, twinkle. Eventually Michel deBoer implemented a setup wizard for some VoIP provider who probably paid for that to offer a decent client to their customers. Might still work01:02
DocScrutinizer05with twinkle on both ends, decent DynDNS or fixed IP, and a tad of NAT fiddling, you could even do direct IP2IP SIP, without any registrar01:04
Juest:p01:04
DocScrutinizer05if by any chance you could use the german locale in twinkle, try it. It's *awesome* (and by me ;-P )01:05
DocScrutinizer05suse has twinkle1.901:06
Juestlol01:06
DocScrutinizer05nfc what they did for twinkle 1.5 to 1.801:07
*** xelo has quit IRC01:07
JuestI guess i should disable encryption thing01:09
DocScrutinizer05ZRTP? why?01:09
JuestBecause thats probably making it get stuck on Connecting01:10
DocScrutinizer05it should 'just work' and remain inactive as long as far end doesn'T support01:10
DocScrutinizer05nope, ZRTP establishes connections absolutely transparent01:10
Juest"Indicate support of ZRTP in signaling protocol"01:10
Juest^ a checkmark01:10
DocScrutinizer05yes01:11
DocScrutinizer05this is just a signal you're sending that your client can handle ZRTP01:11
DocScrutinizer05doesn't cause any known problems01:11
DocScrutinizer05but sure, disable it01:12
DocScrutinizer05can't hurt01:12
JuestThen no idea why its stuck on "Connecting" when i tried to call01:12
DocScrutinizer05ethereal is your friend01:12
DocScrutinizer05cone NAT?01:12
DocScrutinizer05enable STUN!01:12
*** xorly| has quit IRC01:13
JuestAbout that... it works ok when calling over gtalk01:14
*** eijk has quit IRC01:14
Juestit fails to establish ICE when incoming call connects01:14
Juestwtf01:14
DocScrutinizer05gtalk is XMPP iirc01:14
DocScrutinizer05ICE ~= STUN01:14
DocScrutinizer05I guess you have a nasty NAT01:15
DocScrutinizer05open your port 5060 and the RTP ports your service recommends01:15
JuestI am on DMZ01:15
DocScrutinizer05hmm01:15
JuestThe issue is on the other side because.... well01:16
Juestits a default NAT'd network01:16
DocScrutinizer05DMZ still doesn't mean your outbound port also creates an inbound path on same IP:port tuple01:16
DocScrutinizer05particularly for UDP01:16
JuestWhen *she calls* is when the issue happens01:16
Juestnot when i do01:16
DocScrutinizer05*DIS*able ICE/STUN for testing01:16
DocScrutinizer05sorry, I'm out for a beer01:17
DocScrutinizer05ethereal is your friend01:17
JuestICE, UPnP, Auto discover STUN/TURN, own STUN severs, Jingle Nodes01:18
Juestis what's available for gtalk in jitsi01:18
DocScrutinizer05dunno why we're talking jitsi - never even heard of it01:19
JuestBecause i am using that client01:20
Juestit was previously known as SIP Communicator or something01:20
JuestI am here because of Oksana and i am not a maemo user but trying to troubleshoot some maemo issues with her :)01:21
DocScrutinizer05https://www.sipgate.de/basic/signup01:22
DocScrutinizer05so when she's using maemo then why is jitsi relevant in all this?01:23
JuestBecause i am the Jitsi for Windows user01:23
Juest~_~ ffs01:25
DocScrutinizer05and i'm a twinkle on linux user, still how's that relevant for Oksana's problem?01:28
DocScrutinizer05your jitsi doesn't need any special settings to talk to maemo SIP client01:29
JuestWell01:31
JuestLinphone client didnt work01:31
Siceloand we've partly 'proved' that maemo's SIP client is working fine .. deduction - oksana likely has no problrm either01:32
* DocScrutinizer05 thinks it's extremely inefficient and silly to debug person C's problems by talking via proxy person B01:32
DocScrutinizer05even the statements are highly ambiguous - I don't have a clue who's using linphone, on which platform, and why01:34
Juestlinphone has an official app01:34
JuestLOL01:34
JuestShe tried to call me with me using that application01:34
Juestand it did not work01:34
Juestnothing happened on my side01:34
DocScrutinizer05no, linphone app eventually got an 'oggicial' server which is supposed to be crap01:34
DocScrutinizer05original even01:35
DocScrutinizer05err official01:35
SiceloJuest: maybe N900 enforces 'sip:' convention?01:35
Juest...01:35
DocScrutinizer05Sicelo: nope01:36
Siceloah, it appends it .. just tesed01:36
Sicelo*prepend, rather01:36
Sicelo(tested)01:36
DocScrutinizer05check the RFCs listed on twinklephone.com01:36
DocScrutinizer05maemo client is mostly compliant01:37
DocScrutinizer05linphone (server / client) though, NFC if it's even SIP still01:37
DocScrutinizer05tbh linphone never worked for me with sipgate registrar01:38
JuestYeah, linphone clients asks me for Realm Authentication when i try to call to a user on a different registrar01:38
*** lxp has quit IRC01:39
DocScrutinizer05first you need to know if the different registrar even allows dial-in01:39
DocScrutinizer05most don't anymore01:40
JuestEven if it does it asks for login01:40
Juesti think01:40
DocScrutinizer05quite possible, linphone isn't made to handle this scenario I guess01:40
DocScrutinizer05btw neither is maemo telepathy SIP client01:41
DocScrutinizer05the vast majority of SIP clients only knows INVITE via registar server as proxy01:41
*** Kilroo has joined #maemo01:45
DocScrutinizer05http://www.voip-info.org/wiki/view/SIP01:46
DocScrutinizer05https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Session_Initiation_Protocol01:49
Juest:|}01:49
DocScrutinizer05particularly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:SIP_call_flow_between_UA,_Redirect_Server,_Proxy_and_UA.png01:50
DocScrutinizer05((SIP clients only knows INVITE via registar server as proxy)) directly calling the callee's registrar proxy would be directIP2IP SIP which most clients can't do. Sending an INVITE of a different registrar's client to your own registrar is often not working since most dervices have no interest to support calls to other services01:57
DocScrutinizer05s/dervices/services/01:58
infobotDocScrutinizer05 meant: ((SIP clients only knows INVITE via registar server as proxy)) directly calling the callee's registrar proxy would be directIP2IP SIP which most clients can't do. Sending an INVITE of a different registrar's client to your own registrar is often not worki...01:58
DocScrutinizer05~useless01:58
* infobot starts crying and hides from docscrutinizer05 in the darkest corner of the room. :(01:58
DocScrutinizer05neither do they usually support inbound SIP calls from foreign origin01:59
DocScrutinizer05the result of doing such inbound SIP call nevertheless is the far end registrar probably answering a by a 401 UNAUTHORIZED which causes caller's UA to pop up a registration dialog to enter the credentials for that assumed account02:01
DocScrutinizer05note that the INVITE you send to *your* registrar (so it might forward it to the destination) is identical to the INVITE to the foreign registrar if your registrar forwards it. So the foreign registrar will think it's one of their clients who "forgot to REGISTER"02:04
OksanaSicelo, DocScrutinizer: Thanks a lot! As the very least, linphone now manages to sign in (previously got Network Error, tried different settings randomly; Sicelo's settings just work)02:04
DocScrutinizer05Oksana: if you want a decent SIP gateway, feel free to query me for cheating the data on sipgate.de registration02:05
DocScrutinizer05https://www.sipgate.de/basic/signup02:06
DocScrutinizer05it's a trunking service only02:06
DocScrutinizer05means it does SIP only to clients02:07
DocScrutinizer05err customers02:07
DocScrutinizer05it allows free landline call-in though02:07
DocScrutinizer05and of course free SIP calls between customers02:07
DocScrutinizer05they once offered SIP dial-in too, but this feature got cancelled worldwide basically (all trunking providers) since spammers used that feature for unsolicited calls to victims02:09
DocScrutinizer05maybe you find a better service provider in one of the tutorials sites I linked02:11
*** Pali has quit IRC02:12
JuestOk02:12
DocScrutinizer05https://www.google.de/search?q=free+SIP+network+service+provider02:14
DocScrutinizer05http://www.voip-info.org/wiki/view/Free+VoIP+Networks02:15
DocScrutinizer05please forget linphone provider/registrar, it sounds just odd and prone to introduce problems of all sorts02:19
*** auenf has quit IRC02:20
JuestOh dear02:20
DocScrutinizer05I don't think you shpould call me 'dear', Oksana may though ;-)02:22
JuestLol02:22
JuestOksana: ping02:23
*** florian has quit IRC02:27
Oksanapong. And will try out sipgate02:40
Oksana"Oh dear" is just a saying, I guess, not literal ;-)02:43
Juest:)02:47
Juestyes02:47
JuestOksana: And do try logging too please02:47
JuestOksana: apparently got told that skype issue is codec crash02:48
OksanaDo I understand correctly that sipgate requires a street address, and one in Germany at that?..02:49
* Oksana thinks that it is very nice of them to ensure proper emergency call functionality02:49
OksanaThough the website does resemble a maze, somewhat02:52
*** ashneo76 has joined #maemo02:52
* Oksana goes back to https://www.sipgate.de/basic/02:53
Juesto_O?02:55
* Juest is confused02:55
*** M4rtinK has quit IRC02:58
*** gry has joined #maemo03:01
*** auenf has joined #maemo03:04
*** githogori has quit IRC03:11
*** githogori has joined #maemo03:13
JuestHow i can do a P2P SIP call?03:14
Juest^ Oksana asked this btw03:14
gryuseername@ip instead of username@SIP.host03:15
JuestI mean, SIP usually requires an account03:15
Juestin maemo, how to call without a sip account03:16
OksanaJuest: That would need an SIP server installed on the ip. And, I do not see whether there are any SIP servers available for Maemo 5, yet03:16
JuestNot that03:17
Oksanasipwitch sounds interesting03:17
Juest:|03:17
OksanaSIP (Session Initiation Protocol) is in principle a client-server protocol. It is possible for an endpoint of a communication session to implement both a user-agent server and a user-agent client, without the mediation a central switching system. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peer-to-peer_SIP03:19
*** ashneo76 has quit IRC03:23
*** ashneo76 has joined #maemo03:25
DocScrutinizer05((in maemo, how to call without a sip account)) toldya the telepathy client can't do that04:01
Juestdamnit, why always when oksana is "away"04:03
Juestmaemo google talk doesnt seem to have working video04:10
Juesttelepathy*04:11
Juesti am unable to see video and oksana is unable too04:11
*** eMHa has joined #maemo04:20
*** Juest has left #maemo04:21
*** Defiant has quit IRC04:23
*** eMHa__ has quit IRC04:23
*** Defiant has joined #maemo04:29
*** cebreidian has quit IRC04:33
*** Juest has joined #maemo05:27
JuestVideo Call with SIP does not work05:27
Juestits either stuck calling or it dies if attempted from a ongoing call05:28
grycall a test dummy robot instead of calling someone on wifi :p05:29
gryekiga used to have 500@ekiga.net for tests, but maybe it only takes tests from ekiga customers, and you have to find another one for your server, or find a robot account which takes random guest calls05:29
grya tox client for maemo could also be kinda cool05:30
* gry has 4 app ideas already, with zero ui knowledge on this platform ...05:30
OksanaYes, I remember. Help (aka gui for man, or something), calculator-ui (in Gtk, not in Qt4), calculator engine (if I see it correctly, currently calculator engine is closed-source?), sketch (again, Nokia's Sketch seems to be closed source), and now tox plugin for telepathy?..05:33
JuestAnd still would like to troubleshoot our communication issues05:34
*** Oksana has quit IRC06:02
gryTurns out that Firefox instance crashed while doing a Windows upgrade. Darn. I better get my notes together and get some things done.06:07
*** Oksana has joined #maemo06:07
Juest:|06:09
Oksana:?06:10
OksanaBy the way, am I the only one having issues with imgur , does it work for you, or does it not-work for you?06:11
JuestWorks fine06:15
*** SpeedEvil has quit IRC06:21
*** rm_work has quit IRC06:22
*** rm_work has joined #maemo06:25
*** BitEvil has joined #maemo06:25
*** DocScrutinizer05 has quit IRC07:00
*** DocScrutinizer05 has joined #maemo07:00
*** frals has quit IRC07:23
*** cyphase has quit IRC07:48
*** cyphase has joined #maemo07:53
*** cyphase has quit IRC08:04
*** cyphase has joined #maemo08:09
*** flo_lap has joined #maemo08:10
*** githogori has quit IRC08:39
*** githogori has joined #maemo08:50
*** frals has joined #maemo08:55
*** eMHa has quit IRC09:01
*** geaaru has joined #maemo09:02
*** Venemo has joined #maemo09:07
Juestgry now it doesnt let me09:08
Juestreturn09:08
*** Juest has left #maemo09:08
*** gry has quit IRC09:12
*** gry has joined #maemo09:16
*** frals has quit IRC09:21
*** eijk has joined #maemo09:28
*** frals has joined #maemo09:31
*** flo_lap has quit IRC09:35
*** sunshavi has quit IRC09:38
*** eijk has quit IRC09:45
*** eijk has joined #maemo09:45
KotCzarnyvajb: yes, there is /tmp/ file that you can write commands09:45
*** eijk has quit IRC10:07
*** florian_kc has joined #maemo10:10
*** cyphase has quit IRC10:10
*** florian_kc is now known as florian10:10
*** cyphase has joined #maemo10:10
*** cyphase has quit IRC10:32
*** cyphase has joined #maemo10:32
*** Kabouik has joined #maemo10:43
*** xelo has joined #maemo10:51
*** lxp has joined #maemo10:55
*** freemangordon_ has quit IRC10:58
*** freemangordon_ has joined #maemo10:58
*** Kabouik has quit IRC11:01
*** eMHa has joined #maemo11:01
*** xelo has quit IRC11:23
*** M4rtinK has joined #maemo11:40
*** BitEvil is now known as SpeedEvil11:54
*** shamus has quit IRC11:55
*** M4rtinK has quit IRC12:06
*** shamus has joined #maemo12:06
*** eijk has joined #maemo12:13
*** Pali has joined #maemo13:10
*** freemangordon_ has quit IRC13:30
*** xelo has joined #maemo14:15
*** Shapeshifter has joined #maemo14:20
*** zama has quit IRC14:26
*** zama has joined #maemo14:27
*** eMHa_ has joined #maemo14:27
*** M4rtinK has joined #maemo14:28
*** xelo has quit IRC14:29
*** eMHa has quit IRC14:31
*** cyphase has quit IRC14:46
*** zGrr has joined #maemo14:49
zGrrmoin14:49
*** cyphase has joined #maemo14:49
*** eMHa_ has quit IRC14:50
*** Maxdamantus has quit IRC14:51
*** Maxdamantus has joined #maemo14:53
*** Maxdamantus has quit IRC14:59
*** Maxdamantus has joined #maemo15:05
*** eijk has quit IRC15:07
*** shamus has quit IRC15:16
*** shamus has joined #maemo15:17
*** LauRoman has quit IRC15:24
*** LauRoman has joined #maemo15:27
*** eijk has joined #maemo16:07
*** Hurrian has joined #maemo16:08
*** sunshavi has joined #maemo16:09
*** florian has quit IRC16:11
*** eMHa_ has joined #maemo16:38
*** louisdk has joined #maemo16:51
*** M4rtinK has quit IRC17:07
*** eijk has quit IRC17:41
*** eijk_ has joined #maemo17:43
*** florian has joined #maemo18:24
*** Venemo has quit IRC18:25
*** eijk_ has quit IRC18:26
*** krnlyng has quit IRC18:36
*** troulouliou_div2 has joined #maemo18:49
*** krnlyng has joined #maemo18:50
*** arossdotme has joined #maemo19:09
*** arossdotme-planb has quit IRC19:10
*** troulouliou_div2 has quit IRC19:14
*** M4rtinK has joined #maemo19:17
*** Cor-Ai has quit IRC19:19
*** Cor-Ai has joined #maemo19:19
*** xorly| has joined #maemo20:16
*** qt_junkie has quit IRC21:02
*** qt_junkie has joined #maemo21:03
*** M4rtinK has quit IRC21:04
*** zGrr has quit IRC21:09
*** xorly| has quit IRC21:10
*** lobito has quit IRC21:24
*** eijk_ has joined #maemo21:28
*** flo_lap has joined #maemo21:54
*** eijk_ has quit IRC22:06
*** eijk_ has joined #maemo22:06
*** xelo has joined #maemo22:23
*** L29Ah has quit IRC22:24
*** eijk_ has quit IRC22:27
*** xorly| has joined #maemo22:51
*** sunshavi has quit IRC22:57
*** sunshavi has joined #maemo23:15
*** freemangordon_ has joined #maemo23:37
*** xelo has quit IRC23:40
*** louisdk has quit IRC23:50
*** freemangordon_ has quit IRC23:50
*** freemangordon_ has joined #maemo23:52
*** M4rtinK has joined #maemo23:54
*** freemangordon_ has quit IRC23:55
*** Juest has joined #maemo23:56
JuestApparently Voice Calls work properly, so does IM23:56
Juestbut not SIP presence and calls stop working as soon video is attempted23:57
*** louisdk has joined #maemo23:59

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.15.1 by Marius Gedminas - find it at mg.pov.lt!