IRC log of #maemo-bugs for Tuesday, 2010-03-16

*** T7g has quit IRC00:37
*** T7g has joined #maemo-bugs00:41
*** T7g has quit IRC00:53
*** T7g has joined #maemo-bugs00:56
*** T7g has quit IRC01:19
*** mikkov has quit IRC01:23
*** T7g has joined #maemo-bugs01:23
*** mikkov has joined #maemo-bugs01:33
*** andre900 has quit IRC02:00
*** njsf_ has joined #maemo-bugs02:10
njsf_Hi all02:10
njsf_Want to help with some testing. Looked at the wiki pages, but unsure where to start. Any advice?02:11
VDVsxnjsf_, http://wiki.maemo.org/Extras-testing02:20
VDVsxhttp://wiki.maemo.org/Extras-testing/QA_Checklist02:20
VDVsxhttp://wiki.maemo.org/Testing_Squad02:20
njsf_Obrigado Valerio02:20
VDVsxnp :)02:21
njsf_When is the next marathon ? I thought I might still be on time for this weeks one02:21
VDVsxnext weekend02:21
njsf_Oh cool...02:22
njsf_Temple of Diana still up ;) ?02:22
VDVsxthink so, at least last time I went there :D02:38
njsf_:) Cool it has been almost 2 decades since I did the same02:40
VDVsxlol, been there last month :D02:42
*** VDVsx has quit IRC02:44
*** tbf has quit IRC03:01
*** wolf^ has quit IRC03:02
*** wolf^ has joined #maemo-bugs03:02
*** wolf^ has joined #maemo-bugs03:02
*** povbot has joined #maemo-bugs03:47
*** Venomrush has quit IRC04:55
*** njsf_ has left #maemo-bugs06:19
*** fluemo has quit IRC10:06
*** fluemo has joined #maemo-bugs10:07
*** andre__ has joined #maemo-bugs10:09
*** andre__ has quit IRC10:09
*** andre__ has joined #maemo-bugs10:09
*** ChanServ sets mode: +o andre__10:10
*** GeneralAntilles has quit IRC10:57
*** GeneralAntilles has joined #maemo-bugs10:58
*** GeneralAntilles has quit IRC10:58
*** GeneralAntilles has joined #maemo-bugs10:58
*** Venomrush has joined #maemo-bugs12:45
Venomrushandre12:47
Venomrushif a package is fixed in week 1012:47
Venomrushcan i assume it'll be in PR1.2?12:48
Venomrushwhat's the cutoff date for pr1.212:48
andre__please keep that to me. :-) I'll reset TMs myself when I have time again (on holidays from tomorrow on) and know for sure12:48
andre__I don't know.12:48
andre__and no, you should not assume if something is in PR1.2. I will tell when I know by resetting the Target Milestone... :)12:49
Venomrushcool :)12:49
Venomrushhttps://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=849912:50
povbotBug 8499: Music stops when "low battery" hildon banner is displayed12:50
VenomrushTM = 1.2 :)12:50
Venomrushsame for https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8011 as well12:50
povbotBug 8011: Changing volume without unlocking the phone no longer works12:50
Venomrush*i think*12:51
andre__oops must have missed those ones. thanks.12:51
Venomrushand this one too12:52
Venomrushhttps://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=568412:52
povbotBug 5684: History images do not match actual URLs under them12:52
* andre__ grumbles12:53
andre__looks like my query skills need to improve :-D12:53
andre__heh. thanks a lot :)12:53
* andre__ should buy some coffee for this long night12:58
Venomrushhmm when i reopen a bug, it changes state to unconfirm13:11
Venomrushnot ReOpen13:11
andre__aha? which one?13:11
Venomrushhttps://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=704813:11
povbotBug 7048: Route Settings screen is not finger friendly13:11
andre__ah. yeah, makes sense.13:11
andre__REOPENED only happens when it was NEW before being closed.13:11
Venomrushoh right13:12
andre__that one was obsolete anyway :)13:15
*** VDVsx has joined #maemo-bugs14:25
*** tbf has joined #maemo-bugs14:27
*** tbf has quit IRC15:19
Venomrushthink you should go to bed now andre, and be prepare for 9 hours bugday15:25
VenomrushxD15:25
andre__haha, no way, my girlfriend will arrive in a few minutes15:26
andre__oh wait, you just said "go to bed". might work. :-P15:26
VenomrushxD15:26
Venomrushim not looking forward to pr1.2 too much to be honest15:27
Venomrushprefer more features implemented rather fixing lots of random bugs i rarely encountered :\15:27
andre__hmm. we'll see. :-/15:29
*** GAN900 has quit IRC15:30
*** GAN900 has joined #maemo-bugs15:30
*** Venomrush has left #maemo-bugs15:39
*** tbf has joined #maemo-bugs16:00
*** tbf has quit IRC18:24
*** andre__ changes topic to "Bugday: Today, 18:00-03:00 UTC | Welcome to #maemo-bugs | bugs.maemo.orgĀ | http://mg.pov.lt/maemo-bugs-irclog/"18:25
*** tbf has joined #maemo-bugs18:31
*** tbf has quit IRC18:54
*** Venomrush has joined #maemo-bugs18:59
Venomrush1hour till bugday18:59
Venomrush:)18:59
*** tbf has joined #maemo-bugs19:35
*** tbf has quit IRC19:41
*** kimitake has joined #maemo-bugs19:47
*** tbf has joined #maemo-bugs19:57
andre__seems like Nokia has a big screw-up with Daylight Saving Time start in the US. Nine reports so far. Sigh.19:59
*** lma has joined #maemo-bugs19:59
lmaHi all19:59
andre__heja!19:59
* andre__ should probably come up with an agenda or something, humm19:59
andre__I think jukey came up with http://wiki.maemo.org/Bugs:Bugdays . However he is not around yet20:01
lmaOoh, N900 just spontaneously rebooted while sitting on the desk doing nothing20:03
andre__For general ideas how to start triaging, there is http://wiki.maemo.org/Bugs:Tasks20:04
andre__Also I'm looking for people that can confirm any of these issues, as I cannot confirm: https://bugs.maemo.org/buglist.cgi?bug_id=6538,6633,6656,6725,7920,7987,8657,8664,8954,9171,9501,949320:04
* VDVsx searches for his N90020:04
andre__(posting my "Please retest with PR1.2" list probably has to wait for PR1.2 :-D )20:05
andre__taking a look at those Diablo reports that are still open is also a nice idea. Shouldn't be that many anymore as I cleaned up a few days ago20:05
* VDVsx tries 950120:06
* andre__ 's last hours before having holidays. yay :)20:07
lmaSpeaking of which, I have a question:  once the community SSU takes off, what's the best way of handling new Diablo bugs?  I can see two ways, either do it in a single product (like Mer), or create a new version.  What do people prefer?20:08
VDVsxandre__, should I comment with a can't reproduce ? :D20:09
andre__VDVsx, Oh yesh :)20:09
andre__lma: will it have a version scheme like x.2008.foo ?20:10
* andre__ wondering too. good question.20:10
*** tbf has quit IRC20:10
andre__lma: I currently think that a separate product is better, as this is community stuff, and the categories state "Official Apps / Platform". However this is an interesting case. I'm undecided. How urgent is this?20:12
lmaandre__ yeah, current test version is RX-34+RX-44+RX-48_DIABLO_5.2010-09-2_PR_MR020:13
lmaIt can wait20:13
andre__on the other hand you ship official nokia stuff of course in that update. but it's not under the warranty, and it might create wrong expectations on Nokia if they are handled under Official Apps/Platform20:14
andre__"might". I'm unsure, as I said.20:14
* VDVsx can't test #6725 atm : "Open the calendar at 23.59, not the last day of the week." :p20:18
andre__hmm, I hope I don't forget that one later today :)20:18
VDVsxI can change the device time to test, but can mess up my stuff :p20:19
andre__haha, don't do it if you're unsure20:20
andre__I borrowed my second N900 to a friend who's journalist - hence I shouldn't brick mine either :-P20:21
lmawhat's the right severity for a reboot (probably kernel crash) that's unlikely to ever happen again?20:25
andre__in that case, major20:26
andre__if reproducible, critical20:26
lmathanks20:26
* andre__ gives up trying to teach his Fedora machine to accept an IRC SSL certificate and boots Ubuntu. sigh20:27
*** andre41 has joined #maemo-bugs20:29
Venomrushim lucky to have 2x n900 with me today :)20:31
Venomrushwill be losing one of it to a friend this weekend20:31
andre41haha20:31
lmaAnyone have a bluetooth-capable TomTom device?20:34
andre__Hmm, TomTom... I wonder when they will give up because Google and Nokia canibalized the market by providing navigation for free? :-/ See Wayfinder20:39
VenomrushNokia...i wouldn't call it free navigation just yet :)20:43
Venomrushsame for Google20:43
Venomrushuntil both are accessible on any devices then TomTom is dead20:43
lmaI'm asking bugsquad context, just in case anyone can help reproduce bug 9577 ;-)20:46
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=9577 Reboot caused by bluetooth probe20:46
lmaooh, they fixed the bot, shiny!20:46
andre__lma: well, your bug reports are always quite perfect, and most of the stuff I don't understand anyway because I miss technical knowledge, hence I just accept them ;-)20:46
Venomrushi'm currently retesting https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=653820:47
povbotBug 6538: Copying folder(s) with large number of files failed over USB20:47
andre__oh, that weird one20:47
lmaI have very little information on that one, hence UNCONFIRMED20:47
Venomrushi don't have nokia pc suite anymore :\20:47
Venomrushnot sure if it's worth marking as invalid20:48
Venomrushpc suite now asks to upgrade to ovi suite20:48
Venomrushwhich doesnt really work with n90020:48
Venomrush..20:48
lmaI tried to reproduce it once but couldn't (but I'm not running Windows)20:48
* andre__ needs a Windows machine20:48
*** mikhas has joined #maemo-bugs20:49
andre__Venomrush: for bugs like https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8664 , you could use WORKSFORME (however I am also careful with it and prefer to see more than one person stating "Cannot reproduce" first, otherwise some people might interpret it a bit rude to just close it)20:50
povbotBug 8664: Can't close Application Manager from the task switcher20:50
andre__"INVALID" always sounds a bit harsh (though sometimes reports are invalid, sure) :-/20:51
Venomrushah ok, i realised that20:51
lmaSpeaking of which, what does everyone think about bug 9097?20:52
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=9097 Rename INVALID resolution to something more neutral20:52
andre__oh yeah. proposals welcome.20:53
andre__same for opinions on https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=7750 , because I am totally undecided.20:53
povbotBug 7750: Increase Bugzilla votes limit20:53
Venomrushinvalid is needed still in cases where for example, report concerning a function not in the component20:54
Venomrushalthough i rarely see this20:54
Venomrushi feel comfortable if it's removed altogether20:54
lmaI would love some more votes for certain products.  Do you know if it's possible to assign them to components instead?20:55
andre__INVALID and WONTFIX are sometimes nearby, especially in cases of "It's not a bug, it's a feature".20:55
andre__votes are set product-wide20:55
andre__on the other hand, people can remove votes after an issue has been fixed. but of course that's a bit more work for users.20:56
lmaand is the voter-per-product number global?20:56
Venomrushregarding the vote limit, i think it's fine as it is, i never hit that 20 limit, my max at the moment is 11 :)20:56
Venomrushwhen you begin to hit the 20 limit, you should be really thinking about prioritising which bug you want to fix20:56
Venomrushrather than just vote for all the bugs reported20:56
andre__lma: how do you mean?20:56
Venomrushthat way the important one gets more vote, hence more attention20:57
lmaI'm currently maxed out on Chat/Call/SMS, Connectivity, Core, Desktop platform and Email20:57
Venomrushlma, you should prioritise the votes, which one you really want to be fixed20:57
lmaandre__ : does it have to be 20 for every product or is it configurable for each one separately?20:58
andre__lma: ah. gotcha now. no, the vote-per-product number is NOT global.20:58
andre__20/1/3 is per product20:58
andre__and currently set for all of them.20:58
lmaCool, then maybe we can scale them based on the number of bugs reported per product or something20:59
VDVsxgtg, bbl, have a good hunting :p20:59
andre__VDVsx: just a warning that the guy in 9501 can be quite talkative.20:59
VDVsxeheh20:59
*** jukey_ has joined #maemo-bugs20:59
andre__lma: yeah, if it wasn't a fixed number but a procentage value / formula, that would be cool actually wanna file an upstream request? :-P21:00
andre__heja jukey_21:00
jukey_heyjo :)21:00
jukey_are there all bugs fixed and the work almost done? :)21:01
*** VDVsx has quit IRC21:01
lmaI don't think it should be automatic, since that could cause the # of votes to go down as well as up and in that case what do we do with people who have more votes than they are now entitled to?21:01
mikhashi jukey_21:01
andre__jukey_: Yes Sir! I can assure you Sir, PR1.2 will fix all known and unknown bugs and enhancement requests, sir! :-D21:02
andre__lma, oh true21:03
jukey_hehe21:03
jukey_hi mikhas21:04
lmaBut we could get a count of bugs/product, set the lowest one to 20 and adjust the rest proportionally21:04
lma(and maybe re-do once a year or so)21:04
andre__lma: ...and recalculate the count from time to time and adjust accordingly?21:04
lmaAnyway, let's work on some bugs... shall we tackle a specific product, unconfirmed, recent ones or what?21:06
andre__No topic today :) Old still open Diablo tickets would be cool, or21:09
andre__UNCONFIRMED non-moreinfo tickets without internal Alias21:09
* andre__ creates a query for the latter21:10
andre__https://bugs.maemo.org/buglist.cgi?classification=Maemo+Official+Applications&classification=Maemo+Official+Platform&status_whiteboard_type=allwordssubstr&keywords_type=nowords&keywords=moreinfo&bug_status=UNCONFIRMED&field0-0-0=alias&type0-0-0=notsubstring&value0-0-0=int-21:10
andre__hmm, not that many for Official Apps & Platform: 159.21:10
andre__or taking a look at UNCONFIRMED reports in Extras...21:10
lmaDiablo is only 17, unless I'm doing something wrong21:10
andre__uh? cool.21:11
lmaAh, Extras... I asked before but never got an answer: are we supposed to triage those or leave them up to the product contact?21:11
andre__yeah, 17. great. thought it were a few more21:11
andre__I think there's no clear rule, but I can guess that some maintainers/developers might be happy about some help21:12
andre__however we shouldn't mass-close anything or stuff like that, that's counter-productive (not telling lma, but in general here)21:12
lmaShall we clean up the remaining Diablo bugs then?  I assume these are WONTFIX at this stage so we just need to figure out whether they still apply to Fremantle.21:16
andre__yeah, that sounds useful. however they are probably tricky, otherwise I would have nuked them already. Plus at least the last one in the list should remain open :)21:17
Venomrush426 bugs found. UNCONFIRMED in maemo official applications&platform :\21:19
Venomrushhopefully by the end of the night we'll get it down to...21:19
Venomrush100?21:19
Venomrushlol21:19
Venomrushmy query - https://bugs.maemo.org/buglist.cgi?query_format=advanced&short_desc_type=allwordssubstr&short_desc=&classification=Maemo+Official+Applications&classification=Maemo+Official+Platform&version=5.0%2F%281.2009.41-10%29&version=5.0%2F%281.2009.42-11%29&version=5.0%2F%281.2009.44-1%29&version=5.0%2F%282.2009.51-1%29&version=5.0%2F%283.2010.02-8%29&version=unspecified&long_desc_type=substring&long_desc=&bug_file_loc_type=allwo21:20
Venomrushfile_loc=&status_whiteboard_type=allwordssubstr&status_whiteboard=&keywords_type=allwords&keywords=&bug_status=UNCONFIRMED&emailassigned_to1=1&emailtype1=substring&email1=&emailassigned_to2=1&emailreporter2=1&emailqa_contact2=1&emailcc2=1&emailtype2=substring&email2=&bugidtype=include&bug_id=&votes=&chfieldfrom=&chfieldto=Now&chfieldvalue=&cmdtype=doit&order=Reuse+same+sort+as+last+time&query_based_on=N900+New&field0-0-0=noop&type21:20
Venomrushue0-0-0=21:20
andre__Venomrush, you should exclude those with "moreinfo" keyword and those with "Alias | contains the string | int-"21:21
andre__that will decrease the list a bit21:21
lmaOk, let's do UNCONFIRMED/Fremantle then, I can have a look at the Diablo ones another day21:21
andre__sounds good21:22
* andre__ off to have a quick tea in the kitchen with the flatmates, brb21:22
lmaMe too21:23
*** t7g_ has joined #maemo-bugs21:30
lmaI think it will be more productive if we break it down by product, any prerefences?21:30
Venomrushlma, agree21:31
Venomrushlet's do telephony first21:31
Venomrushis this ok?21:32
Venomrushi'll be using andre's query21:32
*** T7g has quit IRC21:32
lmabug 8218 looks related to (perhaps even a dupe of) bug 8454 to me21:34
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8218 device would get stuck or reboot at hangup (bootreason: sw_rst)21:34
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8454 Placing a call in portrait mode gets desktop stuck in portrait mode upon exit.21:34
lmaor bug 5353 actually21:35
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5353 Phone app crashed as call ending21:35
andre__hard to say21:38
andre__need a coredump probably21:38
Venomrushbug 8218 can be close as worksforme21:38
Venomrushcould be related to 3rd party applications, i expect dialcentral is at cause, a clean PR1.1 does not behave like this21:39
lmaWORKSFORME works too, since the reporter can't reproduce anymore21:39
*** MohammadAG has joined #maemo-bugs21:43
lmaLooking at bug 8607, I think I can confirm it and give it a better summary21:46
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8607 SIP call breaks during autoswitching from 3g to wifi21:46
Venomrushi would expect a break here though?21:47
Venomrushcan't have 2 simultaneous 3g&wifi21:47
*** guenther has joined #maemo-bugs21:48
jukey_I don't know a situation where is active more than one connection at the same time21:50
lmaIt's a bad summary, the reporter asks for auto-switching the connection to not happen during a call21:51
jukey_using the gui you also have to choose only one connection at the same time... but maybe the connection should _not_ switch if there is an active SIP call21:51
VenomrushI would expect a break here, as it requires to release the IP address from 3G then renew IP with Wifi.21:52
andre__(ok, back)21:52
jukey_ah :)21:52
andre__yo guenther!21:52
Venomrushbrb (need to restart my compp)21:52
*** Venomrush has left #maemo-bugs21:52
guentheryo21:52
guentherblah "Nickname is already in use."21:52
*** guenther is now known as karstenb_21:52
andre__introducing, though most people here already know: karstenb_ is also maemo.org bugmaster, but mostly hidden, working on technical stuff (e.g. updating Bugzilla)21:53
karstenb_... and hopes to get back to more open triaging soon.21:54
jukey_thanks to bug 9459 I'm now installing maemo5 sdk =)21:55
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=9459 Arch Linux: GUI Installer crashes (TypeError: QWizardPage.registerField has unexpected type 'str')21:55
jukey_hi karsten21:55
jukey_glad to see you here21:55
lmaHi Karsten!21:55
karstenb_Hey guys. :)21:56
lmaOk, just reproduced bug 8607.  Not sure it's in the right product though, any ideas?21:56
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8607 SIP call breaks during autoswitching from 3g to wifi21:56
jukey_wo warst'n, karsten? ;)21:56
karstenb_Ah, jukey_ actually is a jokey_! ;)21:57
jukey_:)21:57
jukey_yes, but now I'm back on the unconfirmed bugs list21:57
andre__lma: if unsure I always leave that job to the Nokians which often don't know either :-P21:58
lmaFine by me :-)21:58
MohammadAGGetting the SYSLOGS and CAMEL logs for https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=808921:58
povbotBug 8089: Clicking notifications for e-mails in folders displays an error21:58
andre__jukey_, SDK installation just because of that? whou. you get an extra cookie ;-)21:59
jukey_indeed... wana see if there is a bug later in the install process (as you know making new bug reports creating more karma points) :-D22:00
andre__heh22:00
lmaHm, I don't think CAMEL_DEBUG is useful for Nokia Messaging accounts but I could be wrong22:01
*** tbf has joined #maemo-bugs22:01
andre__also wondering22:02
lmaDoes anyone care about bug 8658?  One more vote gets it confirmed the easy way ;-)22:03
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8658 Need way to disable cell calls and set SIP/Skype as default22:03
*** Venomrush has joined #maemo-bugs22:04
Venomrushhey andre can u copy the query again?22:05
andre__https://bugs.maemo.org/buglist.cgi?classification=Maemo+Official+Applications&classification=Maemo+Official+Platform&status_whiteboard_type=allwordssubstr&keywords_type=nowords&keywords=moreinfo&bug_status=UNCONFIRMED&field0-0-0=alias&type0-0-0=notsubstring&value0-0-0=int-22:08
jukey_lma: done :)22:08
lmabug 8837 seems INVALID to me, if the VM number isn't present in the SIM then the UI can't call it22:09
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8837 Voice mail number not stored in dial key "1"22:09
MohammadAGlma, if the number is not stored it can be typed in, should it be made into an enhancement?22:10
lmaIt already is.22:11
lmaLeaving it alone then.22:11
MohammadAGoh sorry, haven't checked it22:12
Venomrushthanks andre for the query, rather than doing them by product22:12
Venomrushi think we should do them by oldest first22:12
Venomrushhttps://bugs.maemo.org/buglist.cgi?bug_status=UNCONFIRMED&classification=Maemo%20Official%20Applications&classification=Maemo%20Official%20Platform&field-1-0-0=bug_status&field-1-1-0=classification&field-1-2-0=keywords&field0-0-0=alias&keywords=moreinfo&keywords_type=nowords&query_format=advanced&remaction=&status_whiteboard_type=allwordssubstr&type-1-0-0=anyexact&type-1-1-0=anyexact&type-1-2-0=nowords&type0-0-0=notsubstring&value22:12
VenomrushRMED&value-1-1-0=Maemo%20Official%20Applications%2CMaemo%20Official%20Platform&value-1-2-0=moreinfo&value0-0-0=int-&order=bugs.delta_ts%2Cbugs.delta_ts%2Cbugs.delta_ts%2Cbugs.delta_ts%2Cbugs.bug_status%2Cbugs.priority%2Cmap_assigned_to.login_name%2Cbugs.bug_id&query_based_on=22:12
Milhousewhat did i miss?22:13
lmaHi!22:13
Milhouse:)22:13
Milhousehello - a bit later than planned :(22:13
karstenb_No big deal -- you still got almost 7 hours left to go! ;)22:14
*** andre__ has quit IRC22:14
*** andre900 has joined #maemo-bugs22:15
*** andre__ has joined #maemo-bugs22:15
*** andre41 has quit IRC22:15
Milhousewhat do we think of bug 3975 - my personal pet peave right now...22:15
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=3975 Add option to synchronise inbox with POP3 server22:15
Milhousenot so much the bug, just the way it's being handled... or not.22:15
* andre900 kicks his router22:15
andre__didn't know that Sergio is out of that part :-/22:16
Milhouseno me neither, bit of a surprise22:16
lmaMe neither :-(22:16
andre__let me reopen the internal ticket. though I wonder if that changes much. :-/22:16
lmaSo is the Maemo version of Modest maintained now, and if so by whom?22:17
Milhousethat might help - the initial response is bizarre. the lack of input from sergio is disappointing, can anyone else pick it up? who is working on modest these days? all seems a bit of a mess...22:17
andre__well, internally there is definitely an assignee, but I don't know that guy22:18
MilhouseStarting to hope that Moblin has a better email client, Modest just lurches from one set of bugs to another, with no real direction. Is there even a Modest roadmap? that might be useful.22:18
MilhouseSorry, probably going OT now.22:19
lmaPersonally I just use claws-mail (though I dogfood modest from time to time when triaging bugs)22:20
* karstenb_ grumbles22:20
karstenb_That's a feature request for POP3 protocol abuse.22:20
andre__probably a question for the modest mailing list: https://garage.maemo.org/mail/?group_id=922:20
karstenb_He describes IMAP functionality...22:20
andre__karstenb_, feel free to comment, or discuss with Milhouse here :-D22:20
MilhouseSuspect I may have to consider an alternative - I'd really like to see the stock apps as being the best of breed though22:20
jukey_moblin uses anjal and that is definitely not the best choice atm :)22:20
jukey_but in future... who knows?22:21
lmaWith one or two exceptions, the bundled stuff are usually the worst of breed22:22
lmaThere's a moblin branch in upstream modest too22:22
Milhousekarsten - the odd thing is that "POP synchronisation" (for want of a better description) used to work with the first N900 firmware release, then was partially broken by a release, and according to the internal comment the expected behaviour is that it should not work at all...22:23
andre__this is getting interesting. There's Modest, there's anjal (which is gtk based as far as I know, but I might be wrong), plus Nokia most probably also had their one Harmattan email client plans...22:23
lmaBut both modest and anjal inherit evolution's crappy IMAP engine :-(22:23
andre__IMAPX will land in the next version of e-d-s22:23
karstenb_Milhouse: That's weird indeed.22:24
MilhouseMy take on Modest is that there is a lot of POP/IMAP confusion and it needs sorting out.22:24
karstenb_And apparently, it works as desired for header-only, not downloaded mail.22:24
lmaandre__ yeah, I saw that on the planet a few days ago, maybe there's hope yet22:24
karstenb_So that's an inconsistency.22:24
MilhouseKarsten: Yep, that bug was originally raised against Diablo, so also isn't entirely relevant in some respects (at least, Modest did work perfectly at first, then slowly became more broken with each update)22:25
karstenb_Even though an abuse of the protocol, it probably is the desired behavior for most users these days. Regardless how much I hate to say that. ;)22:25
MilhouseHence my frustration with nobody from the dev team giving a rats arse22:25
Milhouse:)22:25
* karstenb_ is a mail type of hacker22:25
karstenb_And the facts Modest does it for header-only contributes to this...22:25
Milhousekarsten: it's how my old Nokia behaved, I can't understand why anyone would want it to work any other way (with respect to POP, that is)22:25
jukey_we should count mid air collisions! I got my first this evening yet :)22:26
lmaI had two already22:27
MilhouseAndre, Quim is cc'd on 3975 - it would be interested to get a steer on Maemo Modest. At the moment it's looking a bit rudderless.22:27
karstenb_Milhouse: Well, you do realize you actually want IMAP, right? Just saying... ;)22:27
jukey_all in all 3 and still counting22:28
lmanod22:28
*** andre41 has joined #maemo-bugs22:28
andre__Milhouse, I totally agree.22:28
Milhousekarsten: I'd love IMAP! Just that my ISP has no plans to implement it, and I don't have the time to setup my own IMAP server right now (have tried, failed - too much tweaking) and as I say, POP can be made to work just fine... Nokia themselves have proved it (actually it was with the Nokia Messaging client on an N85).22:29
karstenb_Ah, I have read that response (first part) before... :)22:29
MilhouseI've also got an inbox full of 8 week old emails despite a 5-day delete rule.22:30
MohammadAGandre__, got the syslog, it's not the smallest I've saved but it has a lot of private emails in it22:30
Milhousebut enough moaning about modest. :)22:30
MohammadAGoh and the error seems to be the last few lines, should I paste only those?22:30
andre__MohammadAG, feel free drop a private email in case of private information onculded22:31
* karstenb_ now adds "karsten" to his highlight list, just because of Milhouse ;-)22:31
andre__if you're sure that it's only the last line, it's fine22:31
karstenb_Milhouse: But yeah, as I said -- Nowadays, I tend to agree with the bug report. It can be done.22:31
Milhouseah, sorry karstenb :)22:31
karstenb_Even more so, because it is inconsistent with header-only, where it does just that...22:32
Milhouseit's madenning... :)22:32
* karstenb_ has a hint for Milhouse: Tab auto-completion for nicks.22:32
Milhouseoohh - thanks22:33
karstenb_There's a trailing underscore. Someone else took my nick...22:33
karstenb_Handy, isn't it? :-)22:33
lmawhat do you know, that works even on the browser client :-)22:33
Milhousekarstenb_: very :)22:33
MohammadAGandre__, attached the syslog22:36
MohammadAGmoving on to other bugs22:37
andre__thanks!22:37
lmaI have one I'd like to reopen: bug 5699 (warning: may be controversial)22:39
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=5699 WLAN regulatory domain changes to US when no position data available22:39
lmaDoes anyone have a pointer to the *actual* FCC requirements?22:40
Milhousecouldn't that leave some people without wifi connectivity if their router is using a non-US channel?22:40
Milhouses/router/ap/22:40
lmaOf course.  It does.  See also the duplicates.22:41
* andre__ has no clue at all on that one. Do what you think is right...22:41
lmaIt's also much worse when there's no SIM installed, in that case it's stuck to US even with an active GPS fix.22:41
lmaandre__: feel free to set your AP to channel 12 or 13 for a couple of days and see for yourself22:43
Milhousearen't there different regional firmwares?22:43
andre__I'm already happy if my AP actually *works*. I'm not very keen on tweaking a running system if it's not the N900 ;-)22:43
MohammadAGINVALID for me, anyone else experiencing this? https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=913722:43
povbotBug 9137: need to take out battery twice for changing SIM card22:43
lmaThe N900 WLAN chip/driver is "softmac", and that's part of the problem apparently since the FCC have more strict requirements for those (but I haven't been able to find them yet)22:44
MohammadAG(And I change sim cards more than 10 times a week)22:44
karstenb_MohammadAG: Doesn't sound like a software bug to me... ;-)22:44
andre__MohammadAG: feel free to close as WORKSFORME I'd say22:44
andre__plus no response for a month... hmm.22:45
andre__MohammadAG: 10 times a week? What's your job, or hobby? :-D22:45
lmaMohammadAG: haven't come across it, and I change SIMs often too.  Maybe it's specific to a particular SIM or its contents?22:45
MohammadAGandre__, I'm 16, so I wouldn't say I have a job :)22:45
Milhouselma: I can understand the WLAN module default to somewhere when it doesn't have a clue, but surely there is a clue in the firmware... the bug reporter doesn't state what firmware they are using (in terms of region, not number)22:46
MohammadAGandre__, I can't close the bug, only option is Leave as UNCONFIRMED22:46
lmaSyslog output might help with this one22:46
MilhouseI use Global, and despite being in the UK have seen it flip over to the US22:46
karstenb_MohammadAG: Feel free to leave the comment and stuff -- and I can close it based on that.22:46
MilhouseBut if I were using UK firmware, it would be ridiculous if that too flipped to the US22:47
karstenb_lma: ^^ Feel like adding a workforme comment, too, before I close it?22:47
MilhouseOr if it was the Arabic firmware, it should default to something sane for that region.22:47
lmaMilhouse: I'm the reporter :-)  It's an Amsterdam summit loaner device, but I have seen it on the UK variant too22:47
andre__MohammadAG, oh. may I offer you some permissions? :)22:47
MilhouseThen that's wrong, and might be worth adding. Global firmware might be a grey area, but regionalised firmware should default to the region22:48
lmaOh, it flips to US every time it loses cellular network coverage22:48
MilhouseUK -> Europe, Arabic -> ???, Global -> ???, possibly "safest" which is probably US22:48
MohammadAGandre__, well I have some free time so I'd be happy to monitor the Bugtracker :)22:48
lma(gotta go for a while, will be back)22:49
Milhouselma: US has the least available channels I think so could be considered the "safest" option22:49
andre__MohammadAG, here you go, combined with the usual "Please take a look at the Triage Guide and http://wiki.maemo.org/Bugsquad#How_everybody_can_help , and in general if unsure ask first, and use common sense." disclaimer :)22:49
andre__MohammadAG, and feel free to drop a line at http://wiki.maemo.org/Bugsquad#Bugsquad_Members :)22:50
karstenb_yes, please :)22:50
karstenb_Welcome to the bugsquad, MohammadAG.22:51
andre__yay22:51
MohammadAGandre__, thanks :) I'll read the usual wiki stuff, I moderate a site so I have common sense (I think :p)22:51
andre__jukey_, sure with https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8645 being a dup?22:52
povbotBug 8645: External vfat mmc corrupted, file tables damaged? all files missing22:52
andre__MohammadAG, welcome :)22:52
MohammadAGThanks andre__22:52
*** t7g__ has joined #maemo-bugs22:52
MohammadAGand thanks karstenb_ :)22:52
jukey_andre__: hmmm... if you ask me directly: no, I'm not sure22:54
*** Stskeeps has joined #maemo-bugs22:55
*** ptl has joined #maemo-bugs22:55
jukey_maybe the reason is a due but not the consequence22:55
jukey_dupe22:55
*** t7g_ has quit IRC22:56
andre__jukey_, I'm also not sure :)22:56
andre__if in doubt I prefer to keep them separate22:57
*** Noobmonk3y_ has joined #maemo-bugs22:57
* Noobmonk3y_ waves22:57
andre__heja Noobmonk3y_!22:57
Noobmonk3y_hey hey, just an early hello, will join properly when i get home :)22:58
andre__haha, ok22:58
* andre__ will probably be on coffeine and steroids at that time to not sleep yet ;-)22:59
andre__jukey_, can you reopen https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8645 then? TIA :)22:59
povbotBug 8645: External vfat mmc corrupted, file tables damaged? all files missing22:59
MohammadAGMarking as INVALID https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=910423:00
povbotBug 9104: N900 does not charge if MicroUSB cable is connected BEFORE turning on external Power Source23:00
MohammadAGbug reporter uses a "generic" adapter to charge, and not the supplied one23:00
*** JimiDini has joined #maemo-bugs23:00
andre__MohammadAG: either INVALID or WONTFIX, yeah. INVALID seems to fit better, with a comment that this is simply not supported, hence no fixes or investigation by Nokia planned...23:01
andre__errm... JimiDini: you don't use IRC as root, do you?23:02
MohammadAGWONTFIX means - in my opinion - it's a known problem but it won't be fixed, so yep, INVALID it is23:02
andre__MohammadAG, strictly speaking you're totally right, yeah.23:03
jukey_andre__: sure and done already :)23:03
JimiDiniandre__ that's the only user there is on router ;) i use it as irc-proxy23:03
andre__jukey_, thanks23:03
andre__JimiDini: heh... There's enough IRC servers out there that will kick you immediately for that, for good reasons (user protection) :)23:04
MohammadAGanything done about this? https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=908523:05
povbotBug 9085: Camera lens is returned too hard back to home position23:05
JimiDiniandre__ I should mask this fact I guess ;)23:06
andre__MohammadAG, please confirm 908523:06
andre__totally valid issue.23:06
MohammadAGandre__, confirmed, was present in preproduction models23:07
MohammadAGI didn't have one, but the reviewer thought it was a feature23:08
*** JimiDini has left #maemo-bugs23:11
* jukey_ has to go now... the day was longer than expected - wishing all of you a successful bug day/night! :-) 23:12
andre__jukey_, ciao ciao!23:13
jukey_ciao!23:13
*** jukey_ has left #maemo-bugs23:13
MohammadAGreading https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=896523:14
povbotBug 8965: Battery discharges with wall-charger connected23:14
andre__Venomrush: https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8028 - do you have two languages defined in Settings > Text input?23:14
povbotBug 8028: ctrl-space switches input language in X Terminal23:14
andre__because I can still reproduce this here.23:14
andre__(yeah, that part was missing in the steps.)23:14
MohammadAGFrom my experience hal doesn't get updated while charging, as it displays ~40mAh when the green LED on23:14
MohammadAGandre__, bug 8028, CTRL+Backspace switches languages when using ukeyboard23:16
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=8028 ctrl-space switches input language in X Terminal23:16
MohammadAGI'll check w/o ukeyboard23:16
andre__bug8965 - no clue. that report is already... not the best quality23:16
andre__MohammadAG, I can definitely reproduce 8028, no need to check it too :)23:16
andre__I'm just wondering if Venomrush has the same settings (two languages defined) or not :)23:17
MohammadAGoh ok, misunderstood you :)23:17
andre__hehe23:18
lma(back)23:18
Venomrushandre__, yup confirming bug23:19
lmaHold on23:19
lmaSee also bug 776023:19
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=7760 Ctrl + Space enters NUL character in terminal23:19
andre__Venomrush, feel free to reopen and confirm23:19
andre__oh true23:19
lmait's not at all clear which behaviour is correct23:20
andre__I think it's a dup of 7760 now that you say. Thanks for remembering that one :)23:20
Venomrushi would say 8028 depends on 776023:20
lmabut since there are other ways of entering NUL I'd say language switching is the prefered option23:20
Venomrushor dup23:20
lmaIt's not a dupe, it requests the opposite :-)23:20
lma(Fun!)23:21
andre__okay. let me merge them.23:21
andre__done. plus adjusted summary, in bugs.maemo.org and internally23:23
lmaThanks :-)  While on the subject of ctrl+space, anything you can share on the fix to bug 2501?23:23
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=2501 Hardware keyboard doesn't switch Input language when pressing Ctrl+Space23:23
andre__lma: good question. as I don't trust some people internally I should probably try myself first with the internal newer version I'm running here. moment23:25
lmaTry with a non-latin second language (eg Russian or Greek) as those seem to be the most buggy23:26
andre__urgh. I think Urho was wrong23:27
andre__russian is easier for me, I can read that at least :-P23:28
lmaI knew it sounded too good to be true :-|23:28
andre__garr. not fixed at all.23:28
andre__fuck23:28
lmaThat one's been going FIXED -> Oh wait, not really since Chinook :-(23:28
andre__reopening23:29
MohammadAGhttps://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=598123:30
povbotBug 5981: When you tap outside of "Retrieving contacts' info", Hermes reports that "Something went wrong:"23:30
MohammadAGNot sure if that should be confirmed, as it's not a Maemo 5 bug23:31
andre__uh wait. lma, see https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=2501#c31 ?23:31
povbotBug 2501: Hardware keyboard doesn't switch Input language when pressing Ctrl+Space23:31
lmaIt's a Hermes bug, under extras23:31
lmaandre__: yup, but see comment 44 later on23:32
karstenb_MohammadAG: It has a product, so all is well and it belongs there. :)23:33
andre__lma, true23:33
karstenb_MohammadAG: Do you use Hermes?23:33
* karstenb_ reaches for his old standard disclaimers23:33
andre__lma, can I restore the previous state of FIXED and wait for Urho to elaborate?23:33
andre__maybe there is really a fix and I am just too stupid23:34
MohammadAGkarstenb_, yes23:34
karstenb_You don't have to comment or otherwise do anything. You are free to just leave a bug alone, for someone else to pick up. At any time. No obligation whatsoever.23:34
lmaSure23:34
MohammadAGhttps://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=627623:34
povbotBug 6276: After reflashing desktop widgets are still there - but should be on same position23:34
* andre__ been too lazy to test that, though he reflashes a few times a week23:35
lmaI think this might have been a side-effect of bug 743223:35
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=7432 /opt and /home/user  not cleared after firmware reflash23:35
andre__oh true, good assumption23:36
MohammadAGandre__, commented on it23:36
MohammadAGI reflsahed the second day I got the N900 :)23:36
MohammadAG(then found out it was a hardware problem that fixed itself after 2 months)23:37
andre__self-fixing hardware problems? tell us more, I think lots of people are interested in that behaviour. :-D23:38
MohammadAGVibration motor wasn't working (broke on the second day without any abuse), I rebooted the device one day (this february) and it vibrated at startup23:39
MohammadAGnot a real big issue though :p23:39
Venomrushnice :D23:39
Venomrushself healing n90023:39
MohammadAGI've had many hardware problems with my N900, and they seem to fix themselves23:39
MohammadAGcurrent one is that the screen crackles at the top right area23:40
Venomrush1st batch is dodgy23:40
andre__Many people must be jealous of your N900 then. I don't think many N900's do that ;-)23:40
Venomrushso many issues23:40
MohammadAGmine was made in week 47 I think23:40
andre__how can I find out the week?23:40
MohammadAGWeek 51 actually23:41
andre__ah well, I've got an Amsterdam Summit device anyway :)23:41
MohammadAGandre__, it's on the box of the device23:41
MohammadAGUS boxes only I think23:41
andre__ah. heh. okay :-)23:41
MohammadAGhas 51   /   2009 on it23:41
Venomrushcant see this..23:42
MohammadAGgot 32wd_to yesterday23:42
Venomrushyeah got uk box23:42
andre__lma: so you think that https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=6276 only happens because of https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=7432 wasn't fixed, or what?23:42
povbotBug 6276: After reflashing desktop widgets are still there - but should be on same position23:42
povbotBug 7432: /opt and /home/user  not cleared after firmware reflash23:42
MohammadAGVenomrush, UK boxes don't have it23:42
MohammadAG/home/user actually23:42
MohammadAG/opt doesn't contain settings23:42
Venomrushwhen bug day finishes in 5h20, ill be watching lost23:43
VenomrushxD23:43
MohammadAGif only bug day was more than 9 hours long23:43
MohammadAGI'll be going to sleep in 5 mins, have to get up early tomorrow23:43
lmaandre__: before bug 7432 was fixed, a reflashed device would still have leftovers in /home and /opt from the previous installation23:43
povbotBug https://bugs.maemo.org/show_bug.cgi?id=7432 /opt and /home/user  not cleared after firmware reflash23:43
lmawhich explains why the reporter would see 3rd-party widgets magically reappear: both the widgets (in /opt) and the hildon-desktop config (in /home/user) were left intact23:44
MohammadAGdamn, now I have to backup my XChat settings when I reflash :P23:45
andre__lma, I assume the same actually23:45
karstenb_MohammadAG: Also on the UK versions, it seems...23:45
karstenb_49/200923:45
andre__lma, want to close it? :-)23:45
MohammadAGkarstenb_, friend didn't have23:45
MohammadAGhe looked all over his box23:45
karstenb_I just checked mine -- it's on the sticker.23:45
karstenb_Ah, now I see you just said "not for UK" -- Didn't see, I've been away digging for the box. :)23:46
MohammadAGoh so you're from the US?23:46
MohammadAGthought you were from the UK heh23:47
karstenb_Well, I can confirm my UK import to DE has it. ;)23:47
lmahm I have a guest UK box here and the label doesn't say anything like that23:47
karstenb_nah, I'm in Germany23:47
lmait's "Made in Korea" if that matters23:47
karstenb_But wanted an international keyboard, so opted for UK23:47
MohammadAGAll are made in korea AFAIK23:47
MohammadAGkarstenb_, same here, didn't want arabic23:47
MohammadAGironically, Nokia released the ME version without an arabic keyboard23:47
lmaand on the top right the label says "UK CTV BLACK"23:48
MohammadAGtwo weeks after I received my US device23:48
karstenb_heh, tough luck :/23:48
MohammadAGtell me about it23:48
lmaandre__: Best to wait for PR1.2 I think23:48
MohammadAGoh btw, devices with arabic keyboards are manufactured in China23:49
andre__lma, okay, adding it to my PR1.2 checklist23:49
karstenb_Well, at least I *knew* the DE version will have a localized keyboard.23:49
*** VDVsx has joined #maemo-bugs23:49
karstenb_But even despite my own name using umlauts -- I wanted the arrow keys.23:49
MohammadAGsame, arabic has 2 more letters than english23:51
MohammadAGsame with finnish (and german I guess :))23:51
Venomrushkarsten, any news on upgrade to new bz?23:51
MohammadAGWell, I'm done for today, I'll be back tomorrow I guess23:52
MohammadAGNight everyone23:52
* MohammadAG switches to N90023:53
lmaGood night, and welcome aboard!23:53
*** MohammadAG_ has joined #maemo-bugs23:53
MohammadAGnn lma and ty :)23:54
*** MohammadAG has quit IRC23:54
MohammadAG_lousy quit message, forgot to change that :(23:54
Venomrushnight mate23:56

Generated by irclog2html.py 2.15.1 by Marius Gedminas - find it at mg.pov.lt!